Tarnished Treasure

Sherwin-WilliamsSW 9118LRV 38#B9A47E
LRV38 — medium
Undertonegolden · yellow · warm
FamilyYellows & Golds
Best roomsaccent wall · dining room · kitchen
In the Room

What Tarnished Treasure Actually Looks Like

Tarnished Treasure is a medium-depth golden khaki that reads like aged brass or sun-faded leather. It sits right at an LRV of 38.3, which means it has enough body to anchor a room without making it feel dark. In person the color leans decidedly warm, more gold than beige, with a richness that keeps it from feeling washed out. In strong natural light it can brighten to something close to dark honey. In dim or north-facing rooms it settles into a quieter, earthier tone that feels almost like weathered wood.

Undertone Read

Tarnished Treasure Undertones

The dominant undertone is golden yellow, and that is what gives Tarnished Treasure its distinctive warmth. Some designers also pick up a slight ochre or mustard lean, especially in afternoon light when the sun hits it directly. There is a mild debate about whether it carries any green. Most reviewers land on no, calling it purely golden-warm, but a few note that against very cool whites or blue-gray furnishings you might catch the faintest olive whisper. If that worries you, pair it with other warm tones and the gold stays front and center.

Where It Works Best

Where Tarnished Treasure Works Best

This is a versatile mid-tone that works on both interior walls and exterior siding. Inside, it brings warmth to living rooms, dining rooms, and kitchens without veering into builder-beige territory. It is bold enough to serve as an accent wall yet neutral enough to wrap an entire room. Outside, Tarnished Treasure reads like a classic heritage gold, especially handsome on Craftsman and Colonial-style homes where earthy tones feel right at home. Pair it with dark brown or charcoal trim for a grounded exterior palette.

Room by Room

Where to put Tarnished Treasure

Living Room

Tarnished Treasure on all four walls gives a living room the feeling of a warm cocoon, especially when paired with wood furniture in walnut or oak tones. Layer in cream, rust, and olive textiles to play up its golden side. In south-facing rooms expect it to glow; in north-facing spaces it calms down to a rich khaki.

Dining Room

This color thrives under evening lighting. In a dining room, candlelight and warm-toned fixtures push Tarnished Treasure toward a deep gold that makes everything look inviting. Use it on walls with a creamy white ceiling and dark wood or black metal accents for contrast.

Kitchen

Try it on a kitchen island or lower cabinets for an earthy, modern look. Against white or off-white upper cabinets, Tarnished Treasure adds warmth without overwhelming. Brass hardware is a natural match. Avoid pairing it with cool stainless and stark white countertops unless you want it to read more yellow.

Accent Wall

At an LRV of 38.3 it is dark enough to create a focal point but not so heavy it swallows light. Use it behind a fireplace, a bed headboard, or open shelving. Surround it with lighter warm neutrals so the gold tone pops without competing.

Exterior

On siding, Tarnished Treasure looks like a sophisticated take on classic gold. It pairs well with dark brown or charcoal shutters, a cream-colored trim, and a deep-toned front door. The color holds up well in direct sun and reads warmer in shade. A great choice for Craftsman, Colonial, or farmhouse styles.

What to Pair With

What to Pair With Tarnished Treasure

Tarnished Treasure's golden warmth pairs naturally with colors that either echo its earthiness or offer a clean contrast. The coordinating shade Pier (SW 7545) is a deep, grounding neutral that anchors the gold beautifully. For trim, reach for a warm creamy white rather than a stark bright white, which can look jarring against this color's yellow lean. A muted sage green or a soft slate blue makes a nice accent alongside it in textiles and cabinetry.

Compare

Tarnished Treasure vs similar colors

All comparisons are matched against Tarnished Treasure at LRV 38.3.

What to Avoid

Colors that clash with Tarnished Treasure

Cool bright white trim

A stark, blue-based white trim next to Tarnished Treasure makes the gold look abruptly yellow and the white look icy. The contrast feels jarring rather than intentional.

FixSwap to a warm or creamy white trim. Something with a yellow or ivory lean bridges the gap smoothly.
Cool lavender or mauve accents

Purple-based tones sit opposite gold on the color wheel. While complements can work in theory, cool lavenders often make Tarnished Treasure look muddy and dated.

FixIf you want contrast, reach for slate blue or muted teal instead. These cooler tones feel intentional without muddying the gold.
Bright, saturated orange

Because Tarnished Treasure already carries warm golden undertones, adding a vivid orange nearby creates a one-note palette that can feel overwhelming.

FixUse rust or terracotta instead. These deeper, desaturated cousins of orange pair naturally and add interest.
FAQ

Common questions

Tarnished Treasure has an LRV of 38.3. That puts it solidly in the medium range, dark enough to add warmth and depth but light enough that it will not make a room feel small or cave-like.

It leans gold. Compared to a standard beige, Tarnished Treasure has noticeably more yellow-gold undertone. In bright light this reads as warm honey; in dim light it settles into a richer, more earthy tone. If you want something closer to true beige, look at Universal Khaki (SW 6150), which tones down the gold.

Yes, and it is a popular choice for Craftsman and Colonial-style homes. Outdoors it reads as a classic heritage gold. Pair it with dark brown, charcoal, or deep green trim. Keep in mind that strong sunlight will push the color a shade lighter and warmer than what you see on the swatch.

A warm, creamy white is the safest and most flattering trim choice. Avoid cool bright whites, which can create a jarring contrast that makes the gold look overly yellow. For a bolder look, try a deep brown or charcoal trim.

READY WHEN YOU ARE

Start with your photos. Quotes by tomorrow.

Upload a few photos of your home, meet up to four vetted local painters, and get expert color guidance at no cost.

Start a project See it on your home →
1,247Homes consulted
4.9Avg. painter rating
0Spam calls. Ever.